PG&E seizure: Real threat or a bluff?
http://www.elkgrovenews.net/2020/02/pg-seizure-real-threat-or-bluff.html
![]() |
Sen. Scott Weiner (D - San Francisco). | |
By Dan Walters | CalMatters Columnist |
Scott Wiener must be a glutton for punishment.
Just last week, the Democratic state senator from San Francisco
failed, after repeated attempts and many revisions, to win Senate approval of
his ambitious bill to force local communities to accept more multi-family
housing.
Four days later, Wiener took on another, equally daunting issue by
introducing legislation for a state takeover of bankrupt Pacific Gas &
Electric Co. and its transformation into the “Northern California Energy
Utility District.”
Wiener unveiled his bill five days after Gov. Gavin Newsom again
threatened to seize the nation’s largest investor-owned utility if its plan to
emerge from bankruptcy doesn’t meet his criteria.
Newsom, speaking to a Public Policy Institute of California forum,
said he wanted “a completely transformed company” that’s more consumer- and
safety-oriented.
“There’s going to be a new company, or the state of California takes
it over,” Newsom warned, adding, “If PG&E can’t do it, we’ll do it for
them.”
Two days later, PG&E filed a revised plan to emerge from the
bankruptcy it declared a year ago in response to billions of dollars in
potential claims from wildfire victims, saying it “has taken to heart the
governor’s concerns” and “is open to further discussions with the governor’s
office and other stakeholders.”
“Under our plan, the company will emerge from Chapter 11 as a
reimagined utility with an enhanced safety structure, improved operations, and
a board and management team focused on providing the safe, reliable, and clean
energy our customers expect and deserve,” PG&E CEO Bill Johnson said in a
statement.
Previously, PG&E had announced that it reached agreement with
wildfire victims on a $13.5 billion settlement, and competing factions of
bondholders and major stockholders were also supporting its restructuring plan
— but Newsom continued to criticize PG&E’s management and demand more
changes.
Technically, the governor’s approval may not be needed for the
federal bankruptcy court to approve the company’s plan, but PG&E’s access
to a $21 billion special insurance pool to cover wildfire claims, is dependent
on a satisfactory emergence from bankruptcy, thus giving Newsom and the state
Public Utilities Commission leverage.
The revised plan submitted last Friday only partially addresses
Newsom’s demands, leaving the threat of a state takeover, which Wiener’s bill
would authorize, still on the table.
It’s a political, legal and financial poker game that hinges on
whether state seizure is a viable alternative or just a bluff.
“PG&E operates a monopoly as a privilege granted by the state
of California, and that privilege can be revoked. I support public ownership of
PG&E,” Wiener told Bloomberg, a financial news service.
At the very least, it would be costly. PG&E’s stock surged
after Friday’s revised bankruptcy filing. Last year, it dropped to $3.55 a
share but has since climbed to more than $17, giving it a market capitalization
of about $9 billion, but an enterprise value, calculated by Yahoo Finance, of
more than $32 billion, which is probably closer to what the state would have to
pay.
Would the Legislature sanction a seizure? And could a state-owned
utility assemble tens of billions of dollars to pay off stockholders and
wildfire victims, service PG&E’s $25 billion in debts, invest additional
billions in fire safety and still avoid jacking up its consumer power rates,
which are already among the nation’s highest?
Perhaps, but the more likely outcome is a deal under which
PG&E makes a few more concessions to Newsom — particularly ones that are
cosmetic, such as shaking up the corporate board — and he claims a victory.
CalMatters
is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how
California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan
Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary
Elk Grove News is a media partner of Calmatters.
Post a Comment