Elk Grove's misleading statement on fair housing lawsuit settlement - No grace, contrition for breaking the law


This morning, California Attorney General Rob Bonta held a news conference on the settlement reached with the city of Elk Grove for its illegal denial of the Oak Rose supportive housing project. The Old Town-Downtown Elk Grove project, denied by Mayor Bobbie Singh-Allen and her city council in July 2022, sought to build a supportive affordable housing project in the city's cherished special planning area.


The city was fined and must operate under a consent decree-like agreement with the State of California. In an official statement issued after today's news conference, the city offered a misleading narrative.


Notably, the city said "In February, the City settled the dispute with the Oak Rose project applicant that resulted in a relocated project with additional units that better meets the City's affordable housing needs." 


Even though the city reached its settlement with the Oak Rose developer, Long Beach, Calif.-based Excelerate Housing Group, it tried to mislead the public that the matter had been fully resolved. Mr. Bonta addressed the city's implication during today's news conference.


"They [the city] settled with the developer and thought they settled with us," Bonta said. "We are not the developer."


The city further said, "The City is pleased that the State has agreed to settle the matter without significant impact to the City." 


Taxpayers would disagree.


The total cost to date is over $10 million. This includes, but not limited to legal fees paid to the city's outside counsel and EHG's legal counsel, damages, and the cost of the property the city gave to EHG on Elk Grove-Florin Road.


That is money that could have been used for a variety of purposes. 


The last sentence of the official statement was outlandish. It said, "The City is hopeful that in the future, the State will work more collaboratively with cities to partner in the development of affordable housing rather than use precious resources in the pursuit of unnecessary litigation."


What?


The state did not break the law. However, the attorney general's office took the necessary steps to hold Mayor Bobbie Singh-Allen and her city council accountable for breaking rules that are designed to protect the most economically disadvantaged and disabled individuals. 


Unfortunately, as their announcement demonstrated today, City Hall and Mayor Bobbie Singh-Allen lacked the grace to admit their failings and showed no contrition for breaking the law.  


You may not like us, but here you are!
Follow us on Threads @ElkGroveNewsnet
Follow us on Twitter @ElkGroveNews
Follow us on Spoutible @ElkGroveNews
Follow us on YouTube @ElkGroveNews
Copyright by Elk Grove News © 2024. All rights reserved.

Related

Opinion 482924464384729272

Post a Comment Default Comments

4 comments

Deejay Blutarsky said...

"The City is pleased that the State has agreed to settle the matter without significant impact to the City."

That quote says it all! Tone deaf, cowardly leadership using smoke and mirrors to appear larger than life.

Bonta's five year probation period is akin to the City having to walk around with an ankle monitor! Proud Tradition, Bright Future!

Renegade said...

Another example of this City's lack of leadership. Mayor Singh-Allen needs to set an example for all of our citizens, but especially our kids. Be responsible for your actions, admit when you make a mistake, ask forgiveness, learn from your mistakes. She does none of these. There are two candidates running against her in November, isn't it time for a change? Time to find some one who will accept accountability for their actions. This press statement is so full of spin and misstatements isn't worth the cost of the paper on which it was written.

Eye on Elk Grove said...

If, as the city of Elk Grove states in their official response, did nothing wrong, why is the city on probation? And the Mayor and Council want a raise? The Council needs to put that raise on hold for the length of the probation!

Peter Peachfuzz said...

We become the laughing stock of the State... meanwhile our mayor is doing a photoshoot on a yacht in San Diego! Hey BSA - do us a favor and stay there!

Follow Us

Popular

Archives

Elk Grove News Minute








All previous Elk Grove News Minutes, interviews, and Dan Schmitt's Ya' Gotta be Schmittin' Me podcasts are now available on iTunes

Elk Grove News Podcast




item