Chew's Reviews - 'The Butler'

By Gary Chew | August 16, 2013 |  Opens today | Eugene Allen, a Virginia-born African-American, worked as a servant in the Whi...

By Gary Chew | August 16, 2013 | 

Opens today |

Eugene Allen, a Virginia-born African-American, worked as a servant in the White House from 1952 to 1986. Forest Whitaker stars as Cecil Gaines, the lead character who is named after Allen in “The Butler,” a historical display that takes a front-row seat to important events in America during the third and fourth quarters of the 20th century. 

As Gaines, recalling Allen, Whittaker brilliantly plays out the role in parallel to the murder of Emmett Till; the integration of public schools in Little Rock, Ark.; the further strife of the Civil Right Era, including the assassination of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.; the Black Power movement; the assassination of President John F. Kennedy; the Viet Nam War - finally ending during the second term of President Ronald Reagan.

Six past presidents are included in the script: President Dwight D. Eisenhower (Robin Williams), Kennedy (James Marsden), President Lyndon B. Johnson (Liev Schreiver), President Richard Nixon (John Cusack) and Reagan (Alan Rickman). President Barack Obama is seen at the close of the film. 

The script is by Danny Strong, who also wrote HBO's “Game Change,” which dealt with the 2008 presidential campaign. It focused on Sarah Palin as played by Julieanne Moore.

Lee Daniels (“Precious” and “The Paper Boy,” director; “Monster's Ball,” producer) directed “The Butler.” The story was adapted from an article in the Washington Post by Will Haygood - titled, “A Butler Well Served By This Election.”

Whoops Mr. Daniels, Robin Williams doesn't look like Eisenhower. I'm sorry. I like Williams, but he looks so much unlike Ike, one might mistake the famous actor/standup comic for President Harry S. Truman in a movie one might see that dramatically relates to recent, domestic American history. Williams as Eisenhower is a real stretch for me since I can remember both Ike and Harry S. quite clearly. 

Nixon notwithstanding, the commanders-in-chief depicted all struck me as burlesqued – makeup adding to that effect, it would seem. The Watergate president, on the other hand, smacks of all that's dark and serious. Needless to say, Nixon is done well by Cusack - his turn brings a bit of “horror show” to an otherwise opera-ish “The Butler.”

Oprah Winfrey has a substantial part, she plays Gloria, the wife of Gaines, recalling Allen. Other noted faces show up as well: Vanessa Redgrave, cinema's most indefatigable liberal; Mariah Carey; David Oyelowo; Clarence Williams III; Terrence Howard; Cuba Gooding, Jr.; Lenny Kravitz; and Coleman Domingo, a Union soldier in “Lincoln..”

Despite the suds of Daniels' movie, he has an affecting production particularly for younger moviegoers who've only seen vintage black and white video and film of the actual events, and not having experienced them as current TV news coverage as elder Americans did.

(One of my most startling moments watching live television, to this day, was when Lee Harvey Oswald was shot in Dallas while I watched via CBS News. I looked at my wife and said something like, “Did we see what we just saw?”)

Noting a final curious casting strategy in “The Butler” that might be categorized as “Sweetest Revenge Role of the Early 21st century,” Jane Fonda plays First Lady Nancy Reagan. Ms. Fonda got the cameo down really well … body language and all in her bright red frock. Fonda's father, the legendary Henry Fonda (“The Grapes of Wrath,” 1940) would be proud, I'm sure.

Copyright © 2013 by Gary Chew. All rights reserved.
Archived reviews from 2003-2011
Other stuff at

Post a Comment Default Comments

1 comment

Unknown said...

Please rewrite your review so that it might be interesting. Thank you.

Follow Us



Elk Grove News Minute

All previous Elk Grove News Minutes, interviews, and Dan Schmitt's Ya' Gotta be Schmittin' Me podcasts are now available on iTunes

Elk Grove News Podcast